Opened in 1999, Mystic Oaks is a unique community here on Long Island as it is managed by a Homeowner’s Association which handles the lawn maintenance and snow removal, and are all single family detached homes. Instead of being attached side by side, or semi-attached units, Mystic Oaks in Bay Shore are free-standing houses.
A monthly fee covers the maintenance of the common areas in the community. Mystic Oaks can be reached by Sunrise Highway South to Manor Lane to Orinoco Drive and into the community. It’s an All-Age community, but not a gated neighborhood. It is nestled between Brightwaters and West Islip, and is served by The Bay Shore School District #1.
Each home at Mystic Oaks in Bay Shore has a 2 car garage, full basement, front porch, central air conditioning, gas heat and backyard patio. There is a clubhouse and play area within the community.
The Street Names surrounded by Mystic Oaks are Mystic Oaks Drive, Mystic Way, Center Oaks Trail and Pleasant Drive. According to public records of the multiple listing service, in 2013 there was a closed sale at Mystic Oaks in Bay Shore Long Island for $425,000. So far, as of June 2014, there have been sales between $340,000 to $440,000.
UPDATE SOLD 2016 – THROUGH MARCH 2017
These statistics are reflected sales from public records of the multiple listing services and do not include for sale by owner, non-published, non-member, or private sales, or what might be current market values.
Call for curret pricing at our Cell: 631-805-4400
If you are interested in finding out more about Mystic Oaks in Bay Shore Long Island, or want to be alerted when homes become available, call Lawrence “Larry” and Sheila at 631-805-4400 (c).
Sellers: If you would like to list your Mystic Oaks house with us, we can feature it on our popular websites. Call our cell at 631-805-4400.